Agreeing to serve as trustee for a parent’s living trust, a sibling’s special needs trust or a family foundation can often feel like a personal favor, not a legal responsibility with potential liability. However, the law sees it differently. For example, under the Michigan Trust Code, MCL 700.7101 et seq., every trustee owes enforceable duties of loyalty, prudence, impartiality and transparency to the people who benefit from the trust. Violating any of those duties could constitute a “breach of trust” under MCL 700.7901, and it can expose the trustee personally, not just the trust, to a claim.
For family offices with responsibilities over trusts, that exposure is a standing item on the risk agenda rather than an afterthought. National family office practices within large brokerages, such as global powerhouse Aon, now build fiduciary and liability exposure analysis for trusts and trustees into the same comprehensive reviews they use for property and traditional liability coverage, describing that planning for that requires a family-wide mandate rather than a single policy purchase. Breach-of-trust disputes have the potential to be the kind of drawn-out, reputation-sensitive claims that can damage a family office’s mission and which a limited property and casualty insurance program is not equipped to address.
The Personal Stakes of Saying Yes
A breach of trust claim does not require dishonesty. The most common triggers are mismanagement of trust assets, unequal treatment of beneficiaries, accounting errors, missed or delayed distributions and undisclosed conflicts of interest. Under Michigan law, a court can remove a trustee, surcharge a trustee (order the trustee to personally repay the trust for a loss) or award damages from the trustee to a harmed beneficiary. None of those remedies come out of the trust’s assets. They come out of the trustee’s own pocket, which is a hard lesson for someone who agreed to serve as an unpaid favor to family. From the perspective of a trust and its beneficiaries, there is also significant value in maximizing the assets that might be available to satisfy any monetary judgments. Having commercial insurance proceeds available for claims would likely make collection easier and more certain than having to rely on enforcing any judgment against a trustee’s personal assets.
Your Homeowners or Umbrella Policy Will Not Step In
Frequently, people assume that a robust personal umbrella policy covers whatever role an individual takes on. Personal lines coverage is written around personal conduct, not professional or fiduciary roles, meaning that claims arising from a person’s role as a trustee typically fall outside the scope of such personal coverage. A trustee who is sued over how they administered a trust is typically on their own, unless they carry a policy written specifically for that role.
What Trustee Liability Coverage Actually Does
This is a different product from “fiduciary liability insurance”, which is generally written to protect retirement plan fiduciaries under ERISA. A family trust is not an ERISA plan, so an individual trustee needs coverage written for personal trust administration, not a retirement-plan coverage. That coverage, often placed by sophisticated brokers as trustee errors and omissions insurance, can provide various benefits, including:
- Defense costs from the outset of a claim, regardless of whether the claim ultimately has merit.
- Payment of settlements or judgments, with $1 million per claim and in the aggregate a common starting point, with higher limits available.
- Protection for the trustee’s personal assets.
- Coverage on a claims-made basis, meaning the policy responds only to claims first made while it, or an extended reporting period, is in force.
A Few Questions Before You Say Yes
- Read the trust instrument first. It defines the scope of your authority and may include exculpation language, such as indemnity provisions, that may limit, but likely does not eliminate, your exposure.
- Ask whether the trust will pay the premium for trustee coverage or whether that cost falls to you personally. As mentioned, there are reasons why a trust might want to ensure such coverage is in place.
- If you have already been serving as trustee, confirm whether a new policy will cover claims based on alleged pre-policy wrongful acts.
- Remember that co-trustees can share responsibility for each other’s breaches, which is a reason to coordinate coverage rather than assume it already exists.
Coordinating the Document with the Coverage
Warner’s trusts and estates attorneys draft and administer trust instruments and regularly work alongside the firm’s insurance attorneys to review exculpation and indemnification language in the trust itself and to help place the right coverage around it, so the protection matches the duties the document assigns. If a breach-of-trust dispute does arise, Warner’s litigation attorneys are positioned to step in.
It is important to make sure trustee liability issues and potential coverage options are carefully considered before a potential breach of duty claim arises because, by then, it will be too late. Available trustee liability insurance can be a powerful tool in resolving breach claims while minimizing disruption to trust administration, the larger family office, beneficiaries and other family members.
Jason Byrne is a Warner partner in the firm’s Insurance Litigation Practice Group who has advised family office clients on insurance and risk management issues, including trustee liability and other family-office coverage and risk management. Contact Jason or your Warner attorney to evaluate your options.
Learn more about our work with families on our Private Client and Family Office page.
