Careers

Experiences

Industries

Offices

Our Firm

Pages

Our People

Updates

Practices

Warner Norcross + Judd LLP is a corporate law firm with over 230 attorneys serving clients in nine offices throughout Michigan. Among the largest law firms in Michigan, Warner works in virtually all areas of business law.

Michigan Law Firm - Warner Norcross + Judd LLP

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit has set aside both judgments entered against Opti-Luxx, Inc. in a high-stakes pair of patent infringement cases involving illuminated school bus signs. The opinion can be found <a href="https://www.cafc.uscourts.gov/opinions-orders/24-1616.OPINION.11-13-2025_2603126.pdf" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer noopener">here</a>. The joint appellate and patent litigation team from Warner Norcross + Judd successfully persuaded the Court to reverse and vacate jury verdicts that had awarded Smartrend Manufacturing Group damages and an injunction. The decision has captured the attention of national media, including Law360 and Bloomberg Law.

core/paragraph

Smartrend had sued Opti-Luxx in the Western District of Michigan for allegedly infringing both a design patent (U.S. Patent No. D932,930) and a utility patent (U.S. Patent No. 11,348,491) covering illuminated school bus signs. After a jury found infringement and the district court issued a permanent injunction, Opti-Luxx turned to Warner to handle the appeal.

In a precedential opinion issued Nov. 13, 2025, the Federal Circuit vindicated Opti-Luxx on every front:

Utility Patent Reversed: The Court held that no reasonable jury could find infringement under the doctrine of equivalents. The ’491 patent claimed a sign with a “separate and distinct frame,” enabling easy replacement or customization. Because Opti-Luxx’s one-piece design lacked those functions, the Federal Circuit ordered judgment as a matter of law for Opti-Luxx, overturning the verdict in its entirety.

core/list-item

Design Patent Vacated: The Court also set aside the design-patent verdict after finding the district court’s claim construction of “transparency” — interpreted to include both transparent and translucent — inconsistent with the plain and ordinary meaning of “transparency.” The case was remanded for a new trial based on the correct construction.

core/list

The Federal Circuit also vacated the injunction and awarded costs to Opti-Luxx.

This decision is a powerful reminder that precise claim construction and evidentiary discipline are essential in patent cases. The Federal Circuit made clear that district courts should not accept expert opinions at either the claim-construction or trial stage that lack corroborating objective evidence or conflict with the patent record and applicable law.&nbsp;

This case also exemplifies the firm’s ability to deliver a win in complex patent and IP disputes.

Executive Partner

R. Michael “Mike” Azzi

Partner

Vito A. Ciaravino

Of Counsel

Douglas A. “Doug” Dozeman

Gaëtan Gerville-Réache

Intellectual Property

Warner Secures Complete Federal Circuit Victory for Opti-Luxx in Dual Patent Appeal

Warner Norcross + Judd LLP is responsible for the contents of our advertising and this website. Please read our full <a href="/privacy-policy/" aria-label="see privacy policy">privacy policy</a> available on our website. If you have any questions or comments about our website or our Privacy Policy please contact us at <a href="mailto:info@wnj.com">info@wnj.com</a> or 616.752.2000.

Warner Secures Complete Federal Circuit Victory for Opti-Luxx in Dual Patent Appeal

professionals